Are you tired of burning your fingers trying to remove freshly-baked cookies from a hot tray? Or even worse, perhaps you've been using the wrong tool and dropping them! Either way, a cookie spatula could be the answer to your cookie-baking woes. In this article, we're going to look at the ten best cookie spatulas and take an in-depth look at the pros and cons of each spatula.
Why do we need a Cookie Spatula?
Cookie spatulas are ideal for lifting and maneuvering delicate baked goods from one place to another, like from hot oven trays to a cooling rack. Cookie spatulas are also used as a tool to help pry/release the cookie from the tray. They're also good at reducing the mess in the kitchen as you're less likely to damage your cookie when using the correct tool.Not only does a cookie spatula help transfer baked goods in one smooth move, but they're also designed to create minimum damage to your precious cookies! So whether you're an avid baker or just developed a love for all things sweet, a cookie spatula is a handy tool in every kitchen.
The OXO Good Grip Silicone Cookie Spatula stood out to us as one of the best spatulas on the market. It's rounded corners allow it to double as a spoon, which means value for money!
The Ateco Stainless Steel Cookie Spatula is flexible, dishwasher friendly, and well-designed. It's a real bargain for those on a budget.
Quick Comparison: Top 10 Best Cookie Spatulas
1. OXO 1147100 Good Grips Silicone Cookie Spatula
The OXO Good Grips Silicone Cookie Spatula is made from both silicone and stainless steel. It's comfortable to hold and serves its purpose. The stainless steel base of the spatula lifts cookies from the tray seamlessly.
The best feature of this particular cookie spatula has to be the curved edge. The spatula can be used to mix ingredients or scrape the last bits of the mixture from the bowl, which saves on washing up an extra spoon!
The spatula dimensions are 9.2 x 2.6 x 1 inches making it suitable for transferring smaller cookies. However, the angled handle is particularly beneficial as it ensures your hands are kept away from any heat rising from the cookies.
While the spatula is dishwasher friendly (making it easy to clean), and can be used with nonstick cookware, some users reported the silicone splitting which suggests the product might not be all that durable.
2. Ateco Stainless Steel Cookie Spatula
Flexible, dishwasher friendly, and lightweight are just three of the reasons we voted the Ateco Stainless Steel Cookie Spatula as our best pick. Not only that, but the cookie cutter’s thin blade means sliding it under your baked goods requires zero effort!
Lots of customers noted that the angle of this cookie spatula makes it a versatile tool to have in the kitchen. Not only can you use it to transfer cookies, but you can also use it to flip eggs and remove savory items from a frying pan!As for cleaning the Ateco spatula, this cookie cutter is dishwasher friendly and can be cleaned in no time at all with minimal effort. Ateco also sells a matching pie spatula if you want the full set! One con of the Ateco Stainless Steel Cookie Spatula that we noticed when reviewing this product is that some users say the spatula lasted less than a year. Perhaps not as durable as first thought?
3. Fox Run Large Oversized Stainless Steel Cookie Spatula
Measuring 1.5 x 6.5 x 14.75 inches, the Oversized Stainless Steel Cookie Spatula is precisely what it says it is - oversized! This giant cookie spatula is ideal for those who prefer transferring multiple cookies at once instead of one at a time.
The spatula's selling point is that it can be used for multiple functions. Whether that's removing a small pizza from the oven and placing it on a chopping board, or perhaps flipping pancakes in a frying pan, the Oversized Turner has you covered!
Another pro of this particular cookie spatula is the handy loop found on the end of the handle. The loop provides a simple solution to storage as you can hang the spatula from a hook in your kitchen (particularly helpful if it's too big to fit in your draw!). One con we noticed when reviewing this spatula is that some users found it too big to transfer individual cookies (your cookie could slip off the spatula!)
4. DI ORO Designer Series Silicone Turner Spatula
The DI ORO Designer Series Turner Spatula is a versatile tool that can be used for transferring cookies, flipping eggs, and much much more. As the spatula measures 9.5 x 2.75 x 3 inches, it's a little on the small side but works great to pick up individual cookies or items of a similar size.
Not only is the spatula versatile, but it's also comfortable to use thanks to the custom ergonomic thumb placement found on the handle. Other highlights include the non-scratch stainless steel base and multi-use hanging loop for easy storage.One con of the DI ORO spatula is that some users claimed the spatula wasn’t all that heat resistant. The spatula comes with a one year warranty, so if it doesn't perform as well as it should, simply send it back and request a refund.
5. Wilton 570-0270 The Really Big Spatula
If you think picking up one cookie at a time is a little laborious for you, you might want to look at the Wilton Really Big Spatula. This giant cookie spatula can pick up roughly six cookies at a time, which speeds up the cooling process!
If you've not got a steady hand, this particular spatula might be the one for you as the slightly raised sides stop your cookies from sliding off.It has to be said; this particular spatula is possibly targeted at professional bakers or those making large quantities of baked goods. It may seem a little large in a non-commercial kitchen, but it can certainly be used in one! One thing to note is that the spatula doesn’t have a hanging loop which makes it a little tricky to store.
6. Wilton Cookie Spatula
The Wilton Cookie Spatula is a simple device suitable for those on a budget. This dishwasher-friendly spatula is 9-inches in length, making it quite small and easy to handle.
The stainless steel blade is thin enough to seamlessly slide under baked goods on a tray without much effort required. The thinness of the angled blade also ensures that you don't damage any surrounding cookies in the process! However, be aware that some users noted that the blade scratched their trays.The durable non-slip handle is also a selling point as it's both easy to grip and comfortable to hold. As for the color, the blade is silver stainless steel, while the plastic handle is purple and white.
7. Ateco 1365 Cookie Spatula
If you're in the market for a small cookie spatula, then Ateco's 1365 Cookie Spatula could be perfect for you. The blade measures 2.5 x 6 inches and can fit one cookie at a time.
This stainless steel spatula features a beveled edge to help loosen your cookies, and an angled handle to keep your hands back from the hot tray. When it comes to cleaning, the 1365 spatula is dishwasher friendly and easy to wipe down. Some users noted that the rectangle shape of the blade was a little unusual to hold cookies at first.If you like things to match in your kitchen, Ateco also sells a matching brownie spatula and a slotted spatula along with different sized thin spatulas. Whatsmore, Ateco has been producing baking goods since 1905 and pride themselves on creating dynamic and easy to use products.
8. Chef Craft Solid Cookie Spatula
If you're in the market for a budget cookie spatula, then the Chef Craft Solid Cookie Spatula is certainly a good option. This small and lightweight spatula is ideal for removing small cookies and baked goods from a hot baking tray. The blade is suitable to be used with nonstick cookware making it a versatile little tool.
The spatula dimensions are 0.5 x 3.25 x 9.25 inches, so we'd suggest it's not suitable for those keen to maneuver large bakes or multiple batches of cookies quickly.One of the main perks of the Chef Craft Solid Cookie Spatula is that its slight frame makes it easy to store. Simply pop it away in your kitchen draw! Whatmore, the small size makes it easy to navigate a tightly packed tray of baked goods without knocking your masterpieces! However, some users did notice that the wooden handle quickly faded and lost its stain.
9. Kitchen VIA Cookie Spatula
A comfortable handle that's heat resistant and flexible, a small ergonomic design that allows for easy flipping, and a beveled edge to ensure you can gracefully slide under every baked cookie - what more do you want?! The Kitchen VIA Cookie Spatula is a good mid-market cookie spatula suitable for everyday use.
The blade's nonstick metal finish is another pro, as it provides the user with more control and can work on nonstick cookware. Whether you're a home baker or a commercial chef, this little blade packs quite the punch.Many users commented that they use the Kitchen VIA Cookie spatula for more than just transferring cookies. It's also suitable for flipping pancakes, making French toast, and retrieving pizzas from deep pan dishes! The spatula's multiple functions make it great value for money. Note that some users noted the metal blade is not in proportion to the handle, so it can be awkward to hold at first.
10. KitchenAid KO038OHOBA Gourmet Cookie Lifter
The KitchenAid Gourmet Cookie Lifter differentiates itself from other cookie spatulas by having a modern design. This black spatula will blend in seamlessly with a modern kitchen and does everything that a traditional spatula covers!
Note that this particular spatula is heat resistant up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, which is a little cooler than the average heat resistant temperature of 600 degrees Fahrenheit. However, the tool is compatible with nonstick dishes, which means it can be used with almost all cookware.With dimensions of 10.16 x 2 x 1 inches, this cookie spatula ranks on the smaller side of our size scale. Though not tiny, you will only be able to balance one cookie on the blade at a time. While the handle is ergonomically designed, some users found it flimsy to hold.
Types of Cookie Spatulas
There's only really one cookie spatula design on the market, and that's a handle with a flat blade on the end. The variation comes when you start looking at handle length, blade depth, blade size, and angle of the handle. These are all elements that go towards making the best cookie spatula on the market!
Some cookie spatulas are designed purely for cookies, while others are more versatile and can be used for larger baked goods along with savory items, including fried eggs, deep-pan pizzas, and omelets.
Things to Consider Before Buying the Best Cookie Spatula
The size of your cookie spatula is going to play a big part in your decision as there's little point buying a spatula too small. Make sure you check the dimensions of the spatula against the dimensions of your cookie cutter, and if in doubt, always opt for a bigger spatula just in case.
If you're baking against the clock, you might consider buying a cookie spatula big enough to lift multiple cookies at a time.
The width of the spatula isn't the only thing to consider, make sure you check out the varying handle lengths. The longer the handle, the further your hand stays from the heat radiating from the cookies, which is a positive. However, you might find you have less control over the spatula and should then opt for a shorter handled cookie spatula.
Once you've finished baking and lined your baked goods up to cool, you'll probably then turn to the dreaded washing up. You're going to want to buy a cookie spatula that is super easy to clean.
Perhaps you'd prefer your spatula to be dishwasher friendly? Or you're looking for one without ridges for a quicker clean? Always consider how easy the material is to clean too before purchasing.
To get the most out of a cookie spatula, you might want to think if it can be used for multiple things. Cookie spatulas that have a curved edge are particularly handy because not only are they used for lifting and transferring baked goods, the curved edge can be used as a spoon-like instrument in the mixing bowl.
As with all multipurpose baking goods, you want to ensure that the second function of the item hasn't hindered the original purpose. If you opt for a cookie spatula with a curved edge, make sure the material is still top quality to ensure ease of use.
There are two types of material used to make cookie spatulas; silicone and stainless steel. While stainless steel is hardy and durable, silicone offers flexibility that stainless steel can't match.
The material option you choose is completely down to personal preference. Also note that silicone can come in pretty colors and designs in some cases, so if you're looking for a bright and fun cookie spatula, then silicone is the answer.
Also, cookie spatulas should always be heat resistant. If your baking requires higher temperatures than standard bakes, you might want to double-check your cookie spatulas melting point.
Existing Cooking Utensils
Before purchasing a cookie spatula, you might want to look at the current cookware you're using to bake and cool your cookies. If you're using a nonstick tray or pan, you'll need to make sure the cookie spatula purchase won't scratch this surface. In the reviews we've provided above, we've listed 'works with nonstick cookware' if it's a suitable match.
How to Use a Cookie Spatula
Using a cookie spatula is super simple. All you have to do is carefully slide the blade of the spatula under your baked goods and lift them off your tray. You'll want to be careful that you don't knock any of the surrounding cookies while you're doing this, or you could damage them! If you’re a little shaky, you might consider a small, lightweight, and thin cookie spatula like the Ateco Cookie Spatula Steel Blade. If you’d prefer to gather multiple cookies at once, opt for the Wilton The Really Big Spatula.
Advantages of Having a Cookie Spatula
While you might not initially think so, there’s plenty of advantages to having a cookie spatula in your kitchen draw! They’re not just a fun tool to own, they serve a practical purpose and can make a difference between wowing your guests with a delicious cookie, and compromising your baked goods!
- Transfer baked goods easy
- Reduce mess in the kitchen
- Reduces damage to baked goods
- No more burnt fingers!
So there you have it, our best cookie spatulas reviewed and ranked! In summary, if you’re on a budget opt for the Ateco spatula. If you like versatility check out the OXO spatula. Or, if you make large batches of cookies, consider the Oversized Stainless Steel Cookie Spatula. From here on out, transferring baked goods from one surface to another will be a breeze!