Who doesn’t love desserts? Be it a cake, a tart, or a muffin, desserts go straight to the hearts. Another of our favorite desserts is the jelly roll, also known as the Swiss log or roll cake. This is especially popular among the kids but grownups never leave a chance to indulge in this fluffy and soft treat.
And if you are someone who is a baking enthusiast and want to bake restaurant-like jelly rolls at home, it is equally important for you to have the necessary ingredients as well as the right cooking utensils at your disposal to bake it to perfection.
Since jelly rolls are a lot different than the usual cakes they require a shallower and wider tray to be baked flawlessly and choosing the right one makes a huge difference in the final product. This is why we have come to introduce you to the list of the best jelly roll pans that the market has to offer you for you to learn more about it.
The position for our best pick has been grabbed by the very deserving USA Pan Bakeware Jelly Roll Pan. This particular product in our list is an all-in-one option that features durability, versatility, premium non-stick coating, and a super-easy cleanup. It comes in a perfect size and provides a guaranteed fun baking experience.
For our budget pick, we have chosen the second product from our list which is the Gotham Steel Jelly Roll Baking Pan. This product is the best bang for your buck starting from its eye-catching color to its sturdy build and its dishwasher-friendly feature. Together with its unique and high-quality coating and high temperature withstanding nature, this product has it all to take your baking skills to the next level.
Quick Comparison: Top 10 Best Jelly Roll Pans
1. USA Pan Bakeware Jelly Roll Pan
The first product on our review article is from the USA Pan brand which guarantees a commercial-grade quality making this Jelly Roll Pan fit for both home kitchens and professional use.
- Material: Aluminized steel
- Dimensions: 15 x 10 x 1 inches
- Weight: 1.9 Pounds
- Warranty: Lifetime warranty
Being made from heavy-duty aluminized steel not only ensures its durability but also maintains an excellent airflow within the pan due to the micro-texture it comes with. This feature assures you that your baked food receives even heating throughout and does not end up with hot-cold spots. Not only that, it makes both cooling and heating time effective making it very convenient for use so that you do not have to wait around too long for your food to be baked perfectly.
Ensures your safety!
The pan comes equipped with a non-stick Americoat coating which is a patented silicone coating that not only facilitates easy food release and cleanup but also is certified as PTFE, PFOA, and BPA free. This means that the pan will not impregnate the food you are cooking by releasing any sort of toxins and poses no health risk.
Versatility or nothing!
As much as this bakeware is effective for baking perfect jelly rolls, it is ideal for other bakery items like cookies and cakes. In addition to bakery items, it can be used for baking meat and veggies as well.
You can wash this pan by using mild soapy hot water and a gentle sponge may be required. You do not have to go through aggressive cleaning as the food does not stick to the bottom or corners of the pan.
What we liked: We loved how this pan does not warp or require any greasy item before pouring the batter on it. Moreover, the lifetime warranty that it comes with gives us manufacturer’s words for durability and we do not have to look for a replacement for the pan anytime soon.What we didn’t like: The issue with this product may be its coating which may come off if washed or used aggressively but this can be minimized by gentle handling.
2. Gotham Steel Jelly Roll Baking Pan
The next product on our list is from Gotham Steel and stands out because of its spectacular color which makes this pan an attractive choice for you.
- Material: Aluminum combined with titanium
- Dimensions: 17.59 x 11.81 x 1 inches
- Weight: 2.5 Pounds
- Warranty: No warranty
The build of this pan also like the former one and is made up of heavy gauge aluminum however, is combined with titanium which boasts durability for extended use. Not only that, the patented “Ticerama” coating gives it a ceramic finish and makes it appropriate for easy clean, and quick food release. The coating is also scratch proof.
The material of the pan makes it ideal for uniform heat division which is needed for baking soft and moist jelly rolls.
Dishwashers it is!
When we say this pan is easy for cleanup, we mean that you wash this in your dishwasher as well. For a smaller mess, you can use a cloth to wipe the residues also.
What we liked: Along with all the other amazing features, we loved that this pan can withstand a temperature of 500 degrees Fahrenheit which makes it ideal for not only baking jelly rolls but for veggies and chicken as well.
What we didn’t like: Even though the pan claims to be scratch-proof, it scratches very easily. Also, due to its shape, residues of the food cooked can be collected in some spots which require additional hand scrubbing.
3. Doughmakers Jelly Roll Bake Pan
The third position in our list is grabbed by the Doughmakers Jelly Roll Bake Pan which is one of the first choices of professional bakers because of features like embedded marble pebble texture that ensures a premium non-stick experience.
Additionally, the unique texture also facilitates good airflow which is essential for even baking. It does not leave your food with unusual burnt spots as the heat is evenly distributed through the pan.
- Material: Aluminum
- Dimensions: 15 x 10 x 0.75 inches
- Weight: 1 Pound
- Warranty: No warranty
The pan is constructed from 18 gauge commercial grade aluminum material so you do not have to worry about the longevity of this product or look for alternatives after a few times of use. Because this pan is made from aluminum alloy, it features super-fast heating and cooling which means that your baking time will be reduced by a huge margin. Not only that, you can readily serve your food right after taking it out of your oven as it cools off pretty quickly.
One of our most favorite features...
The non-stick nature of the pan does not require you to use additional grease or cooking sprays before placing your batter on it. This makes this pan a healthier choice and a good alternative for people who are not into very oil-infused food.
If you are a person who feels responsible for the environment then this product may be ideal for you. Being made from recyclable aluminum, this poses minimal risk to the environment. Additionally, unlike most non-stick cookware, this pan is PTFE and PFOA free which means your food will not be contaminated with any sort of harmful additives.
The pan is not completely scratch-proof but the scratches will not decrease its baking capacities.
For restoring the appearance of the pan, it is highly suggested that you hand wash them with mild detergent/soap.
What we liked: The pan is very light weighted and resists rust like a champ! Moreover, the pan has handle areas which give us a good grip of the pan and makes handling easy.What we didn’t like: Since the pan comes with no chemical additives, some brown patches can develop on it making it lose its non-stick feature after extended use. Another thing that we disliked is that the pan has a paper pasted on it when it is new which is relatively harder to get rid of.
4. CHEFMADE Rimmed Baking Sheet Pan
This product from CHEFMADE is on our favorite list because of its super effective non-stick coating and commercial-grade quality which not only gives excellent baking performance but also looks after the safety of your health.
- Material: Carbon Steel
- Dimensions: 15.55 x 10.63 x 0.98 inches
- Weight: 2.2 pounds
- Warranty: Replace or refund if the customer is not satisfied
But that’s not all...
This champagne gold color pan is made with highly durable heavy-duty carbon steel with a thickness of 0.8mm which ensures uniform heat conduction preventing over-browning of your jelly roll. The material also helps in rapid heating and cooling. Furthermore, the pan features enhanced edges which do not only maintain stable baking conditions but also prevent it from warping.
Forget your worries…
The silicone coating that pan comes with is non-Teflon and free from any other sort of harmful chemical additives (PTFE & PFOA) that do not contaminate the food even at high temperatures. It also ensures quick food release without causing any damage to the food or leaving behind stubborn residues.
Our favorite because...
Like the former one, this product also has a premium non-stick feature which does not require any extra greasy item beforehand. This makes this pan diet-friendly and perfect for people who want to avoid oily food.
It is suggested that you do not soak it in water. You are to thoroughly dry the pan (using an oven for this is advised as soon as you can) if you soak it in water by mistake. Following this instruction will allow you to extend the service life of the pan by many years.
What we liked: Not only the pan takes less time for baking giving us more time to spend with our friends at a party but also is highly energy efficient as a small amount of heat will raise the temperatures of the pan by a huge deal and this is a plus point for.What we didn’t like: What we disliked in this pan is that it warps even at 390 degrees Fahrenheit which is a problem for us. Another problem with this product is that it has a hard cleaning process and can hold waste even after washing.
5. Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan
This product from Chicago Metallic comes with a very traditional design that has a dedicated build for baking the perfect Jelly Roll.
- Material: Steel
- Dimensions: 15 x 10 x 1 inches
- Weight: 2.2 pounds
- Warranty: Lifetime warranty
It stands out because...
The pan features a wire rod and reinforced rims which guarantees the durability of the product. The rims of the pan are provided for extra resistance against warping and any sort of dents.
The traditional outlook of the pan makes it a simple and sober choice for you. Additionally, the pan comes uncoated which lacks to provide the advantages that non-stick bakewares provide which includes easy cleaning. With this one, you have to go through a tougher cleaning process because there is a risk of food residues sticking to the bottom or the corners of the pan which requires extra attention while cleaning.
The pan is not solely used for baking jelly rolls and can be used for both making single sheet dinners or as a tray for reheating leftover food.
The product comes with dishwasher-proof features but like all the other ones, it is suggested that you hand wash them for a longer period of use.
What we liked: We loved how the product comes with a lifetime warranty making it a worry-free purchase. The dishwasher-friendly feature also made this our favorite as we do not have to allocate extra time for washing this kitchen accessory separately.What we didn’t like: There were two problems that we faced, both of similar kinds. The bottom of the pan scratches very easily leaving behind marks. In addition to this, after washing the pan if not dried properly drip stains were seen to be left behind.
6. OXO Good Grips Jelly Roll Pan
The product next on our list is from OXO Good Grips and the feature it is most popular is because of the pan being equipped with premium double-layered ceramic non-stick coating. This particular feature can protect against rust, stain, corrosion, and scratches all at once.
- Material: Aluminized Steel
- Dimensions: 10 x 1 x 15 inches
- Weight: 1.3 pounds
- Warranty: No warranty
The coating is further able to stop any kind of discoloration of the pan and you do not have to worry about your food sticking to the bottom or corners of the pan as it is the best at preventing sticking. Additionally, the pan is constructed from heavy-gauge aluminized steel that ensures very good heat conduction which is essential for baking.
The micro-texture patterns on the pan ensure an even heat division across the pan providing stable baking of your food. The texture also helps to restore a good airflow in the food and minimizes surface contact between the food and the pan which further helps the food to not stick to the pan.
Strength and grip...
The pan is designed to have square roll edges which give the pan a greater strength. In addition to that, the edges also help you to get a good grip on the pan which makes handling the pan super-easy. Moreover, it also puts you at a lower risk of dropping the hot pan on your feet or the floor while putting it in or out of the oven.
Even though the product offers such amazing features, it does not support versatility. It will work just fine with jelly rolls but be careful not to bake any kind of proteins using this pan. This pan is also not safe for use in dishwashers, meaning that you have to allocate extra time for washing this pan and cannot put it with your regular kitchen utensils.
What we liked: We loved that the pan has a strong build as it is made up of aluminized steel but yet has lightweight and can be used for a long time. Furthermore, the sidewalls are straight and the corners are plain without any texture, this makes cleanup easy.What we didn’t like: There were some problems that we faced with this one. The pan is not warp-resistant and bends even when exposed to low heats for a long period. In addition to that, the pan comes with a coating that has the chemical additive PTFE which is a major downside of this product. Moreover, even though it comes with a non-stick coating, if any food residues are left behind the micro patterns of the pan make it difficult for cleaning.
7. Wilton Jelly Roll and Cookie Pan
If you are someone who is a regular baker and is a jelly roll pan, this product from Wilton may be just the right choice for you because it comes at the ideal size for baking jelly roll and is the lightest (0.55 pounds) of all the products reviewed so far which makes it super convenient for handling.
- Material: Aluminized
- Dimensions: 1 x 11 x 16 inches
- Weight: 0.55 pounds
- Warranty: No warranty
Constructed from premium quality aluminum alloy, this tray despite being super light, provides you with a warp-resistant feature even when exposed to high temperatures and is fit for extreme cooking conditions. The aluminum body also ensures its durability and facilitates an even heat distribution for stable baking.
Perfect baking performance...
Together with the perfect heat distribution and warp resistance, the pan can effectively bake fluffy and porous jelly rolls for you. Not only that, it can withstand the weight of heavy and big meat cuts like pork shoulders or briskets as well as a full turkey!
For more effective results, you are advised to wash the pan with warm soapy water before and after using it.
What we liked: Extra goodies are always appreciated! We loved that a recipe book is included with this kitchen accessory for the newbies. It is also dishwasher safe which makes it easy for cleaning as we can wash it with other kitchen utensils as well.What we didn’t like: As the pan does not come with a non-stick coating, sliding food from the pans are harder and inconvenient. Moreover, uncoated pans are more prone to scratches and dents.
8. Nordic Ware Jelly Roll Pan
For the eighth entry in our review article, we have chosen the jelly pan from a trusted brand, Nordic Ware which is made up of aluminum which does not give the pan its strength but also ensures premium heat conductivity.
- Material: Aluminum
- Dimensions: 15.25 x 10.75 x 1.13 inches
- Weight: 1.35 pounds
- Warranty: Lifetime warranty
Not only that...
The commercial-grade quality pan is made from the purest form of aluminum making it ideal for rust protection as well. In addition to this, the rims of the pan are strengthened with galvanized steel. Together with the galvanizing and the sturdiness of the pan makes it super-resistant towards any sort of denting or scratches.
What more does it offer?
It features a high-quality gold color inner non-stick coating which additionally protects against scratch. This also facilitates you with sliding and taking your food off the pan without causing any sort of deformation to the food.
What we liked: We loved the consistency in the heat distribution which results in the perfect browning of the food leaving behind no hot-cold or burnt spots. This is also effective in cutting down the baking time tremendously, in turn making it energy efficient.What we didn’t like: The pan comes with an explicit instruction that it should be hand washed. This means that we have to allocate extra time for washing the pan since it requires additional attention.
9. KITCHENATICS Jelly Roll Baking Pan
If you are someone who is looking for a pan that will last you a lifetime without you having to worry about looking for replacements, this product in our list from KITCHENATICS should be on your priority list because of its extreme strengthening build which makes it ideal for heavy-duty use.
- Material: Pan: Aluminum, Rack: Stainless steel
- Dimensions: 15.6 x 10.6 x 1 inches
- Weight: 2.9 pounds
- Warranty: Lifetime warranty
Not just durable…
Being constructed from heavy gauge aluminum alloy, this pan features a very ideal size for baking the perfect jelly rolls. Furthermore, the pan is powered by reinforced rims which prevent the overflowing of food when subject to high temperatures. Not only that, with this pan you do not have to worry about warping since it provides full protection against it.
With this pan, you will not only be restricted to baking jelly rolls but also all the other kinds of desserts that require a similar pan. Furthermore, it is not for desserts only! Regardless of whether it is chicken wings, crispy bacon, roasting vegetables, or your favorite steak, this pan has got your back.
The best part…
The pan is accompanied by a 304 stainless steel cooling rack which prevents rust like a champion. The cooling rack comes with multiple welds which make it fit for holding a weight of 45 pounds on the grate without causing any damage.
The three cross support bars in the rack make it warp proof and the 1 inch lifted legs helps in maintaining excellent air circulation for the food you are cooking. The space between the rack and the pan also facilitates even heat distribution which is essential for big cut meats like briskets, roasted recipes, or other meat preparations in general.
The pattern of the grate is such that they are closely packed which acts as a safeguard against food from falling through the grids. The rimmed edges of the rack also play a significant role by not letting the juices or gravy slip down from the food so that it stays intact, making it taste better.
Moreover, another advantage of the rack is that it is dishwasher friendly so you do not have to go through the trouble of hand scrubbing it.
How to use it?
The pan and the cooling rack complement each other perfectly. You can place the rack over the pan with your food on top inside the oven. The pan in this case will collect any excess oil that drips from your food without creating a mess inside your oven which would otherwise require additional cleaning.
The rack as mentioned earlier is basically used for cooling your food.
What we liked: The product comes with a free recipe ebook which is an absolute upside for us as it is loaded with a variety of recipes that we can try with this kitchen accessory. Additionally, we loved that the pan-rack combo can withstand heat as high as 575 degrees Fahrenheit which provides us a larger room for trying out different food and cooking styles.What we didn’t like: The only downside to us of this amazing combo is that it does not come with a non-stick coating which makes food release difficult. This can be minimized by using more greasy items or parchment paper which will prevent the food from sticking to the pan.
10. 360 Stainless Steel Jelly Roll Pan
For the last and final entry on our list, we have chosen the jelly roll pan from 360 which comes constructed from a surgical grade stainless steel with multi-core technology. The significance of this technology is that for super-fast heating and consistent heat distribution.
- Material: Stainless Steel
- Dimensions: 18 x 1.5 x 11.75 inches
- Weight: 2.0 pounds
- Warranty: Lifetime warranty
Another characteristic that makes this unique and our favorite is that it features a 0.7mm thickness which lacks in other bakewares the market offers you. This feature makes the pan more sturdy and warp resistant.
Ensures your safety…
The premium surgical grade quality of the stainless steel surface does not only ensure quick heat conduction but also poses zero risks to your health compared to other non-stick coating cookware.
Instead of using harmful additives which are usually used in non-stick cookware that may impregnate your food with toxins, this particular product uses a dry sanding process to give the surface a smooth finish. This not only makes the pan look attractive but also facilitates easy cleanup.
The pan features ergonomic handles on either side of the pan for better handling and puts you at a lower risk of dropping the pan on your feet or the ground creating a mess.
Additionally, the pan is fit for use at temperatures as high as 500 degrees Fahrenheit. Moreover, it is also dishwasher-friendly meaning you can wash this with other kitchen utensils as it requires no additional care.
What we liked: We loved that it comes with a lifetime warranty which means you can make a worry-free purchase as you do not have to continuously seek replacements.What we didn’t like: We could not find any cons of this product so far and it could satisfy all our baking needs.
Important considerations while buying the best jelly roll pan
The market offers you a wide variety of jelly rolls pan each with a different size and it is solely your decision which size fits your needs the most. If you have a big family or are hosting parties for your kids regularly then you should go for a pan that has a wider surface so that you can bake larger batches of these sweet treats. However, if you are an individual living alone, then the smaller pans would be more useful for you.
The size will also depend on the storage space you have at your house. Larger pans require bigger storage whereas compact ones can be easily stored in your kitchen drawers. On another note, smaller pans give you greater ease of use.
The material your jelly pan is made up of is positively correlated with the jelly roll that you will end up with. The better the material of the pan, the more fluffy and porous your roll will be.
The market in this aspect also offers you plenty of options. The most common ones are aluminum, anodized aluminum, stainless steel, and aluminum steel. Each of the four has its advantages and disadvantages so it is another thing that is dependent on your preference to choose which will work best for you.
Durability is directly related to the material with which your pan is made up of. If you choose a pan that easily scratches or dents then it is obvious enough that will not last long. Pans which are made up of high quality aluminized steel or aluminum tend to be more durable than others available to you.
One way of ensuring durability is to go for pans that come with a warranty. This way you will not have to continuously look for alternatives or replacements and it will be a one-time investment.
Maintenance of the jelly roll pan is important when it comes to restoring the durability of the product.
People usually do not prefer hand washing their utensils and want something that does not require any extra care and can be washed with other kitchen utensils in a dishwasher. So, it is wise to go for pans that are dishwasher friendly.
However, since the dishwasher aggressively cleans the pan, it may decrease its service life which is why it is suggested to hand wash the pans. Moreover, pans that come uncoated requires hand washing anyway as they are more to have food residues left behind in them.
5. Non-stick coating
Non-stick coating on a jelly roll pan is almost a necessity for those who abhor washing and scrubbing their pans. If your jelly roll pan does not come with a non-stick coating there is a significant chance that the food residues will be left behind on your pan which requires extra care while cleaning.
Moreover, pans with non-stick coating require the use of the additional greasy items to prevent your food from sticking to the bottom which may not be a good alternative for health-conscious people.
But while choosing your non-stick pan be very careful to check whether it contains any harmful chemical additives or not which may migrate to your food at high temperatures causing a risk to your health.
The jelly roll pans offered to you at the market may come with different embedded textures. These patterns do not just make the pans look good but play an important role in maintaining a good air circulation so that the food you are baking browns perfectly.
Even though this feature is not an absolute necessity in a jelly roll pan but the ones with handles are more convenient for use. This is because it gives you a greater grip on the pan preventing you from dropping it or getting your mitts dipped in the cake batter.
Extra accessories are always welcomed! Some pans come with a cooling rack that has multi-purpose use. They can both act as a cooling rack for cookies and a grilling grate for roasts.
Many other foods can be cooked using a jelly roll pan and if you want to use the same pan for baking other food or reheating leftovers then your choice of jelly roll pan should be able to withstand varying temperatures since some of the pans are unfit for high temperatures and warp when exposed to high heat.
Even though it can easily be misunderstood that jelly roll pans are dedicated only to bake jelly rolls as its name suggests but it can be used for other kinds of baking/cooking as well!
Regardless of this fact, while you are choosing your choice of jelly roll pan be sure to consider the above-mentioned features before you make your purchase. This way you will not repent your investment and be able to buy the best jelly roll pan among the ones the market has to offer.